Blogging, Books, Fiction, Non Fiction, Self Publishing, The Writing Process, Writing, Writing Tools

Do You Prefer a Short Story or a Novel? #AmWriting

When I was eight years old, I would spend hours writing short stories.  There was no real plot to speak of, and the characters were a re-hash of my friends, family, and teachers, but I loved writing above all the other games that an eight-year-old would play, ever hopeful that I would be an author one day.


Fast forward thirty-five years and I’ve now published five books with my sixth (Guardians of the Lost Lands) due out in December.  I was also highly commended in the Self-Published Book Awards 2014 for my non-fiction title, How I Changed My Life in a Year.  Writing is my life, and I couldn’t be happier about that.

When I was younger, writing short stories was my happy place.  I get bored very quickly, and so writing fast-paced tales that were under 2,000 words was perfect for my Gemini nature.  When I started to take my writing seriously and began publishing my work, the short stories became a distant memory.  The plots and characters I created needed time and space to get into trouble and dig themselves back out again.  I also began writing non-fiction for the personal development/self-help genre which needed a higher word count.


It was when I joined my creative writing group that I began to write short stories and flash fiction again.  One of my favourite writing tasks was to develop a flash fiction piece from a photograph/image (my YA trilogy was conceived in the same way).  Even though I was scribbling shorts again, I still favoured a longer story.

When I was approached to submit a short story for the anthology, Creeps in the Night, I was nervous and unsure if my story would be up to the task.  It surprised me how fast I had fallen into the full-length novel writing zone.  Fortunately, the theme was creepy tales, which hooked me in straight away.

I re-wrote one of the flash pieces I’d written for my creative writing group, edited it and submitted.  I was elated to have it accepted.

The House on the Hill, appears in the anthology, Creeps in the Night, which is available as eBook and paperback, alongside a host of incredible authors.


It was fun to step out of my comfort zone and write a short story; it’s also an honour to add this anthology to my catalogue of published works.  Author, Rayne Hall, promotes the use of writing short stories to help sell your full-length novels in her appropriately titled, Writing Short Stories to Promote Your Novels.

Whether you write 120,000-word epic romances, 30,000-word novellas, or blog posts and articles, writing is still writing.  This is something to be celebrated, shared and enjoyed.  So, if I ever get asked to write another short story, I’m going to jump at the chance.

Do you write short stories or full-length novels?  Maybe you prefer to read a full-length novel over anthologies?  I’d love to hear your thoughts so feel free to leave me a comment below.

34 thoughts on “Do You Prefer a Short Story or a Novel? #AmWriting”

    1. I have Victoria Aveyard’s new YA release, Glass Sword, ready to start reading and this is 444 pages! I’m so excited to read it but I find myself putting it off and reading the shorter novels on my pile. I need to lock myself away for a week I think 😉


  1. I used to write shorts, and have been working primarily on novels for a few years, but I was just this night hankering to write some shorter pieces again! The idea of working on something that I can finish more quickly is appealing! Though I worry about getting distracted from my main project. I haven’t tried flash fiction or using an image for inspiration. Might give it a go…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I love flash fiction and have started to use it as a ‘warm up’ exercise to my writing day. I’ll pick a topic (or use an image) and fire off a 500 word piece. They are normally unrelated to my main project but it certainly gets the brain going! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I really enjoy reading short stories. Sometimes I just don’t have the time to devote to a full-length novel so a book of short stories I can dip into works really well. And it’s a real skill to write a satisfying short story – every word really counts when you have so few to work with (which is why I don’t write many!)..

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This is exactly why I’ve started to read more anthologies, Alison. It’s like having a sorbet between your starter and main course 😉 I find that it helps me to break the spell from one long novel to the next, and if you find a satisfying story then all the better – no matter the word count. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Generally, I prefer novels, though I do like novellas too – but sometimes a short story anthology is just the thing, isn’t it? And I think Rayne is so right – when I published my short story collection, Nine Lives, I put the first chapter of my novel What It Takes in the back. A week later, I put What it Takes on 99p special offer – and sold so many it got into the Top 1000 on Amazon, so it definitely works! Alison’s so right about every word counting, too – I’ve recently written a novella and have had to remind myself how to ‘contain’ more than you do for a novel – a short story is like the same process, ten times over! Also, you have to have a really, really good ending. That’s the hard bit! Why not put the anthology you’re in on Rosie’s review team list? That would be good!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s great news about getting into the Top 1000 on Amazon – proof that Rayne’s advice is spot on. I believe that I over-think short stories and therefore never quite like what I’ve produced. I once wrote a flash fiction piece about abuse and sent it off to a competition and it got ‘highly commended’. It was such a gritty and unusual story that I didn’t think it would get anywhere. I guess that was my lesson! 🙂 Great idea about submitting the anthology to RBRT.


  4. Novels, or novellas at least, for reading because I like to luxuriate in the length of the piece, though short stories work nicely for quick blasts. On the writing front, I tend to write more shorts, though I do enjoy the pleasure of having more space to work in a novel.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Reading? Hmm… Both. I love losing myself in a good novel or even a series but I love short stories, too. I am always amazed at what writers can accomplish with a small word count. My favorite thing to write is flash fiction or short stories.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I’ve written both (never published – still working on that!) but I love short fiction. I really enjoy jumping into a short story, especially when it’s a tense scene, and seeing what happens. Even though some end abruptly, I find those finishes very satisfying!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Currently working on a novel based on shorts I wrote years earlier. Great shorts are hard to write since there is no room for error. But, writing an entertaining story over 400 pages is also challenge, one more lated to adequate breadth.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Sacha. I’m with you on that one, writing shorts is still tricky for me, although I do love flash fiction. Have you heard of You have to write a 154 character story in a text message. Some of the winning stories are amazing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.